Class Warfare Clarion- All the News That Fits, We Print.

On November 27, 2011, in prime position on the front page, The New York Times published a lengthily essay by David Kocieniewski entitled A Family’s Billions, Artfully Sheltered. This piece specifically targets, for reasons unknown, Ronald S. Lauder, an Estée Lauder family heir, as the subject and example of how wealthy families protect their income. Mr. Kocieniewski conveniently fails to mention that this is a widely utilized practice is not only the provenance of the wealthy; millions of American families of middleclass and upper middle class backgrounds create trusts for tax sheltering and asset protection.

The tone of the piece, its title and the sheer hypocrisy feeds the theme of the current presidential campaign being waged by Mr. Obama; that is, the rich are to be despised and for the most part haven’t earned the largesse they inherited- as the son of a fabulously wealthy fashion icon, Mr. Lauder developed aristocratic tastes-and grand aspirations-at an early age. Further on in the essay we are told that while the family’s wealth was created by hard work and ingenuity, it was bolstered by aggressive tax planning, a skill that has become Ronald Lauder’s specialty. So let me understand this. Is the Times suggesting that Ronald Lauder is the only individual who practices aggressive tax planning? The sainted Kennedy’s, whose money came from the illegal sale of alcohol during the prohibition, amongst other things, don’t protect their wealth? The Clintons have no trust for their daughter nor do they have a Foundation they have established to protect their wealth, which undoubtedly was gained by purely legal and appropriate means.

Adding to the deceit, slight of hand and smarmy tone of the piece (a de facto front page editorial decrying the evils of ill-gotten wealth and calling for class warfare) is the paragraph describing the establishment of family trusts on the part of the Lauder family- Significant portions of his inherited stock are held in family trusts, which reduce the ultimate estate tax. Mr. Lauder and his wife have also established their own family trusts, allowing them to bequeath their wealth to their heirs with minimal taxes. Wow, what insight, what perspicacity! Only Ronald Lauder and his wife, with their inherited filthy lucre, have established such trusts; no one else in the United States has. Bill Gates and Warren Buffet are Democrats and Lauder is a Republican. I have to wonder why those two former names were not submitted as additional exemplars of this legal practice?

The information about Lauder’s receiving the Carnegie Foundation’s Medal of Philanthropy is written towards the end of a rather lengthily pontification pillaring the rich; I’m so shocked! Furthermore, even closer to the end of this rubbish is, finally, the intellectually honest description of why the tax breaks for art exist and if one knows anything about the Lauder Family, they not only meet the goals and intent of the tax law, but also exceed them. What do the Clintons contribute to society and what about their trusts and specifically Bill’s new found financial gains (remember when the President was so strapped, he had to have a defense fund)? What about the Strauss family, right here in Dallas? Are we supposed to believe they have no tax shelters and trusts? Now tell me about Gates and Buffet themselves who have utilized trusts to avoid the payment of these same income taxes to the American people, as does Lauder. Do you wish to throw in any of myriad Democrat Goldman Sachs executives for flavoring?

This pretense, sanctimony and blatant disregard for what used to be the rules of good journalism has become the basis for the new motto of The New York Times, that is, All the news that fits, We print. What was once editorial is now front page. What was once a read of perfect grammar is now a dangling jumble of participles. What was once scrupulous fact checking and sourcing is now the scandal of a fabricated front page.

This once great newspaper has lost readership and credibility. This latter state of affairs is perhaps the unkindest cut of all. Why? It was this paper of record to which we looked for verification of what the politicians told us. It was to all the credible newspapers that we used to look for some semblance of truth. The Times as well as all the rest have squandered this responsibility having now erased the line between fiction and fact, the last line of public scrutiny and defense from an overly abusive political class. Now there is nothing except the 24 Hour News Cycle- the new televised and readily available National Enquirer for what has become minds that are anything but inquiring. That fact, coupled with, a) increasing and near total national ideological polarization, b) the President’s declaration of Class Warfare and c) economic instability, fear and uncertainty (all secondary to either leading from behind or voting present) is what may eventually lead to open civil disturbance and violence.

The New York Times, the national paper of record, will be one of those institutions and organizations responsible for that chaos and violence by violating and mocking the public trust. Shame on them and shame on everyone else in the news business! Most of all, shame on us because if we are not part of the solution, we are the problem!

You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

9 Responses to “Class Warfare Clarion- All the News That Fits, We Print.”

  1. Nice post how long i should wait for next one?

    • newheart807 says:

      Thanks.

      As you liked the posting, we would welcome your RSS subscription and your liking us @ Health of the Nation on Facebook for more upcoming and ongoing information.

      I will be posting new blogs every Monday and Friday afternoons. I would be delighted to have you as a subscriber.

      Also, you can stream our program live on hotnationtalk.com as well as get the podcasts. Please feel free to e-mail comments or questions.

      I appreciate your taking the time to reply to the blog and I trust that there will be more topical information in the future to spur healthy conversation between you and your friends and family. Should you think it appropriate I would be thrilled if you ask friends and family to subscribe to the blogs and Like us on Facebook as well.

      Thank you again,

      Mitchell Brooks, M.D.

    • newheart807 says:

      Today after 5 PM!

      As you like the posting, we would welcome your RSS subscription and your liking us @ Health of the Nation on Facebook for more upcoming and ongoing information.

      I will be posting new blogs every Monday and Friday afternoons. I would be delighted to have you as a subscriber.

      Also, you can stream our program live on hotnationtalk.com as well as get the podcasts. Please feel free to e-mail comments or questions.

      I appreciate your taking the time to reply to the blog and I trust that there will be more topical information in the future to spur healthy conversation between you and your friends and family. Should you think it appropriate I would be thrilled if you ask friends and family to subscribe to the blogs and Like us on Facebook as well.

      Thank you again,

      Mitchell Brooks, M.D.

  2. Generally I don’t learn article on blogs, but I would like to say that this write-up very pressured me to take a look at and do it! Your writing style has been amazed me. Thank you, quite nice article.

    • Dr. Brooks says:

      That’s nice of you to say, particularly about a very touchy subject.

      As you enjoy the blogs, please tell more of your friends about the radio site and especially the blog site as well. Would you also do us the honor of asking your friends (as well as you) to subscribe to the blogs by clicking the RSS logo on the front page of the website? It would be greatly appreciated and know that I will always endeavor to produce incisive and timely pieces on issues that affect the Nation’s Health!

      We would appreciate you downloading the podcasts if you missed the program and also your liking us on Facebook @ Health of the Nation Remember, you can also can catch our broadcasts live on Sundays at 5PM to 6 PM Central on 570 AM, KLIF by going to the website and clicking on the Streaming bar.

      Thank you again for the time you took to read the blog and to comment.

      Mitchell Brooks, M.D.

  3. Can I simply say what a relief to find somebody who truly is aware of what theyre talking about on the internet. You positively know tips on how to convey a difficulty to mild and make it important. Extra individuals must learn this and understand this facet of the story. I cant believe youre no more widespread because you undoubtedly have the gift.

    • Dr. Brooks says:

      Well thank you and perhpas you can help to make me more widespread.

      As you enjoy the blogs, it’s so easy to share the radio program and your comments with your friends through our Facebook page Facebook @ Health of the Nation

      Would you also do us the honor of asking your Facebook Community (as well as you) to subscribe to the blogs by clicking the RSS logo on the front page of the website?

      We would appreciate you downloading the podcasts if you missed the program.

      Remember, you can also can catch our broadcasts live on Sundays at 5PM to 6 PM Central on 570 AM, KLIF by going to the website and clicking on the Streaming bar.

      Thank you again for the time you took to read the blog and to comment.

      Mitchell Brooks, M.D.

  4. Good day! Would you mind if I share your blog with my twitter group? There’s a lot of folks that I think would really appreciate your content. Please let me know. Many thanks

    • Dr. Brooks says:

      Yes, absolutely please DO share.

      As you enjoy the blogs, it’s so easy to share the radio program and your comments with your friends through our Facebook page Facebook @ Health of the Nation

      Would you also do us the honor of asking your Facebook Community (as well as you) to subscribe to the blogs by clicking the RSS logo on the front page of the website?

      We would appreciate you downloading the podcasts if you missed the program.

      Remember, you can also can catch our broadcasts live on Sundays at 5PM to 6 PM Central on 570 AM, KLIF by going to the website and clicking on the Streaming bar.

      Thank you again for the time you took to read the blog and to comment.

      Mitchell Brooks, M.D.

Leave a Reply